
vs
Defensa Y Justicia vs Gimnasia M.
Fri 11 Sept · 19:15Estadio Norberto Tito Tomaghello, Florencio Varela
Home side first and left in every table.
In short
In short
- The call
- Defensa Y Justicia to win 1-0. We make them 48 percent against the market's 47; the draw is the live alternative at 29.
- The one stat
- Gimnasia M. have generated 0.96 expected goals a game across their last seven away competitive matches, and conceded 1.42.
- The risk
- Defensa have one clean sheet in 13 league matches, and Módica, eight goals in seven Clausura games, is fit again.
- The calls
- Safer: Defensa Y Justicia or draw at 1.27. Riskier: under 2.5 goals at 1.71. Four more leans on the board.
The situation
This is the Zone A summit, and the Defensa y Justicia vs Gimnasia Mendoza prediction turns on one mismatch: the leaders do not travel like leaders. Gimnasia M. arrive with 16 points from eight Clausura matches (W5 D1 L2) and are unbeaten in four. Defensa Y Justicia have 14 from eight (W4 D2 L2) and lost 1-0 at Lanús last Sunday. Neither club is in anything like a crisis. Gimnasia have W8 D3 L4 from their last fifteen competitive matches and drew 2-2 with Boca Juniors last time out; Defensa's one defeat in five was a 0-1 at a Lanús side that kept them to three shots on target. There are no sackings in the air, no squad sales, no protests at either gate.
Both coaches are settled enough to judge. Darío Franco took his first Gimnasia session on 29 March and has taken W8 D3 L3 from the 14 competitive matches since, building a side that plays without the ball, averages 47 percent possession and counters. Julio Vaccari returned to Defensa in late May for a second spell and has W4 D2 L3 from nine competitive matches, one of those defeats a Copa Argentina exit at Racing. What has changed under Vaccari is at the back and at home: across their last seven home competitive matches Defensa have 1.46 expected goals for and 0.70 against, three straight home league wins and four unbeaten.
The week itself has been quiet on both sides. Neither played midweek, so it is five days of rest for Defensa against six for Gimnasia. The one piece of real news is Agustín Módica. The Clausura's leading scorer with eight goals in seven matches missed the Boca draw with a muscle problem, and Gimnasia still scored twice without him, but he is back in training and the Mendoza previews put him in the XI. Tomás O'Connor, who limped out of that Boca match with a muscle strain, does not make it.
The markets
Double chance
Defensa Y Justicia or draw
Our home-plus-draw number is 77 percent against the market's 75; Defensa are unbeaten in four at home with 1.46 expected goals for and 0.70 against over their last seven there, and Gimnasia have taken 1.00 points a game from seven away matches.
EvidenceGoals tablexG trendProbable XIs
Total goals
Under 2.5
We make the under 60 percent against the market's 55: both venue splits show over 2.5 in 40 percent of the last 10, the league is at 2.08 goals a match with over 2.5 in 36 percent of 375 fixtures, and Gimnasia make 0.96 expected goals a game away.
EvidenceGoals tablexG trend
Result & goals
Match result
Defensa Y JusticiaPrice 2.02
3/5We make Defensa 48 percent to the market's 47: a 70-point Elo deficit is cancelled by home advantage, and Defensa have won their last three home league matches while Gimnasia have 1.00 points a game from seven away.
EvidenceGoals tablexG trendHead-to-head
Level handicap
Defensa Y JusticiaPrice 1.47
4/5The same 48 percent view with the draw returned rather than lost, which matters when our draw number is 29 percent and Defensa have drawn four of their last 10 home league matches.
EvidenceGoals tableProbable XIs
Total goals
Under 3.5Price 1.23
4/5The wider version of the same read: Gimnasia have gone past 2.5 goals in 40 percent of their last 10 away league matches and Defensa in 40 percent of their last 10 at home, against a market figure of 76 percent for the under.
EvidenceGoals tablexG trend
Cards
Total cards
Under 4.5Price 1.80
2/5Jorge Baliño has shown 2.71 yellows a game in seven matches this year against a league average of 4.88, enough to counter team rates of 4.6 and 5.1 cards a match in a fixture with no derby edge.
EvidenceRefereeDiscipline
Confidence is the desk's conviction, 1–5; each evidence chip jumps to the chart or table behind the lean. Analyzed markets are part of the DeepPreviews membership — free to explore during early access. Prices are indicative market averages, not an offer.
Match sheet
- Kick-off
- 19:15 Buenos Aires time
- Friday
- Referee
- Jorge Baliño
- 2.71 yellows per game in 2026
- Weather
- 14 °C, light rain possible
- Light southerly breeze
- Rest
- 5 days vs 6
- Neither side played midweek
- Standings
- Zone A summit
- Gimnasia 16 points, Defensa 14, from eight each
Part one
Analysis
Why the leaders are not the favourites here, what the expected-goals numbers say about both recent runs, and where the cards line sits.
01Goals
Start with quality, because it frames everything else. Gimnasia M. rate 1642 on the Elo scale to Defensa's 1572, a 70-point gap in the visitors' favour. Home advantage in this league is worth roughly 60 to 80 Elo points. That is the whole story of a 2.02 against 3.66 price: on neutral ground Gimnasia are the better side, at the Tomaghello the two are level, and the market has read it correctly.
The counted form pulls the same way. Gimnasia have taken 1.00 points a game from their last seven away competitive matches (W2 D1 L4), scoring 1.14 and conceding 1.57, on 0.96 expected goals for and 1.42 against. Their last two away wins flatter them badly: 3-0 at Independiente came from 0.65 expected goals against 0.89, and 3-2 at Gimnasia L.P. from 1.98 against 1.48. Defensa, by contrast, have underperformed at home rather than over: 1.46 expected goals for and 0.70 against across their last seven there, three league wins in a row and unbeaten in four.
None of that points to a goal glut. Gimnasia have gone past 2.5 goals in seven of their 14 league matches and in only 40 percent of their last 10 on the road; Defensa in eight of 13 overall but 40 percent of their last 10 at home. The league itself is running at 2.08 goals a match with over 2.5 landing in 36 percent of 375 fixtures. Both venue splits and the league baseline argue the same low number, which is why the under is the shape we push rather than the handicap.
Gimnasia M. score 1.57 a game across their last 14 league matches but 1.00 in their last 10 on the road, where they concede 1.40.
Sample: Liga Profesional 2026: last 13 and 14 league matches; splits from the last 10 at home and the last 10 away.
| Metric | Defensa Y JusticiaHome | Gimnasia M.Away |
|---|---|---|
| Goals scored per game | 0.921.2 at home | 1.571.0 away |
| Goals conceded per game | 1.691.2 at home | 1.211.4 away |
| Both teams scored | 62%70% at home | 50%50% away |
| Over 2.5 goals | 62%40% at home | 50%40% away |
Bold marks the better figure in each row. Small numbers are the venue split: the home side at home, the away side away.
Gimnasia's 3-0 at Independiente came from 0.65 expected goals; Defensa have beaten their expected-goals line at home three times running.
Sample: Clausura 2026 league matches with expected goals recorded: 7 for Defensa Y Justicia, 8 for Gimnasia M.
Defensa Y JusticiaHome
avg xG 1.42 · avg xGA 0.99
1–1D
Aldosivi (H)
2–1W
Deportivo Riestra (H)
3–0L
Estudiantes L.P. (A)
2–1W
Newells Old Boys (H)
1–1D
Velez Sarsfield (A)
1–2W
Belgrano Cordoba (A)
1–0W
Platense (H)
Gimnasia M.Away
avg xG 1.42 · avg xGA 1.44
1–0W
Central Cordoba de Santiago (H)
1–0L
San Lorenzo (A)
2–0W
Union Santa Fe (H)
1–0L
Instituto Cordoba (A)
3–1W
Talleres Cordoba (H)
2–3W
Gimnasia L.P. (A)
0–3W
Independiente (A)
2–2D
Boca Juniors (H)
xG forxG againstOldest match on the left.
One competitive meeting this year: Gimnasia M. won it 2-1 in Mendoza on 4 May, level at 1-1 at the break, with Defensa ahead on shots 11-8 and on corners 7-2.
0
Defensa Y Justicia
0
Draws
1
Gimnasia M.
4 May 2026·Liga Profesional Argentina
Gimnasia M.2–1Defensa Y Justicia
Home side listed first. Winner in bold.
What this supports
Full board ↑Double chance
Defensa Y Justicia or drawSafer
Price 1.274/5Total goals
Under 2.5Riskier
Price 1.713/5Match result
Defensa Y Justicia
Price 2.023/5Level handicap
Defensa Y Justicia
Price 1.474/5Total goals
Under 3.5
Price 1.234/5
02Cards
The two teams argue for cards and the referee argues against them. Gimnasia collect 2.9 a game across their 14 league matches, Defensa 2.0 across 13, and 10 of Gimnasia's 14 and 10 of Defensa's 13 have gone past 3.5 cards. Gimnasia's heaviest counts come in defeats: seven cards in the 1-5 at Independiente Rivadavia, five in the 0-1 at Instituto, four in the 0-1 at San Lorenzo.
Jorge Baliño is the counterweight. He has shown 19 yellows and no reds in seven matches this year, 2.71 a game, against a league average of 4.88 yellow cards per match across 375 fixtures. Over a 104-match career he sits at 4.32, so this year's number may regress, but the recent read is a referee letting play run. With the market split almost evenly at 1.91 over and 1.80 under, the referee is the tie-breaker and it points below the line.
Jorge Baliño has shown 19 yellows and no reds in seven matches this year, 2.71 a game, against a league average of 4.88.
Sample: 2026 season, 7 matches refereed
Jorge Baliño
7 matches this season
league average
Gimnasia M. take 2.9 cards a game across 14 league matches to Defensa's 2.0, and 10 of those 14 passed 3.5 cards.
Sample: Liga Profesional 2026: 13 matches with statistics for Defensa Y Justicia, 14 for Gimnasia M.
| Metric | Defensa Y JusticiaHome | Gimnasia M.Away |
|---|---|---|
| Cards shown per game | 2.0 | 2.9 |
| Cards in their matches per game | 4.6 | 5.1 |
| Over 3.5 cards | 77% | 71% |
Bold marks the better figure in each row.
What this supports
Full board ↑Total cards
Under 4.5
Price 1.802/5
03Corners
Corners are analysis here, not a call. Defensa win 5.0 a game and concede 4.5 across their 13 league matches, so their fixtures average 9.5; Gimnasia win 4.1 and concede 4.9 across 14, averaging 9.0. Both sit just above the league's 8.68 per match.
The shape matters more than the total. Defensa's biggest corner counts come when they hold the ball and get Barbona and Hausch into wide areas: nine against Vélez, six against Platense, seven in Mendoza in May against Gimnasia's two. Gimnasia's own corner count drops away from home, one at Gimnasia L.P. and four at Independiente, because they defend deep and break. Expect Defensa to own that column and for it to mean less than it looks.
Defensa win 5.0 corners a game to Gimnasia's 4.1, and their matches average 9.5 against a league figure of 8.68.
Sample: Liga Profesional 2026: 13 matches with statistics for Defensa Y Justicia, 14 for Gimnasia M.
| Metric | Defensa Y JusticiaHome | Gimnasia M.Away |
|---|---|---|
| Corners won per game | 5.0 | 4.1 |
| Corners conceded per game | 4.5 | 4.9 |
| Corners in their matches per game | 9.5 | 9.0 |
| Over 9.5 corners | 46% | 50% |
Bold marks the better figure in each row.
04The numbers that matter
- 0.70
- Defensa expected goals against, per home game
- Across their last seven home competitive matches. It is the best defensive stretch Defensa have put together this year, and it arrived under Vaccari.
- 0.96
- Gimnasia expected goals, per away game
- Last seven away competitive matches, against 1.42 conceded. The leaders' road results have run ahead of their road performances.
- 8
- Módica goals in seven Clausura matches
- Eight of Gimnasia's 14 Clausura goals came from one player, who has just come back from a muscle problem that cost him the Boca draw.
- 2.71
- Baliño yellow cards per game in 2026
- Nineteen yellows in seven matches against a league average of 4.88 per match, the reason the cards lean sits under rather than over.
Three of those four are counted from completed matches. The referee figure is the one to treat with care: seven matches is a small sample, and Baliño's 104-match career average of 4.32 yellows sits much closer to the league norm.
Part two
Who plays, and how
One striker carries most of Gimnasia's goals and has just come back from injury. That, and a midfield reshuffle, is where this match is decided.
05Team news
Módica has eight of Gimnasia's 14 Clausura goals and is back in training; O'Connor's strain forces one change in midfield.
Defensa Y JusticiaHome
No reported absences.
Gimnasia M.Away
Agustín MódicaST
muscle problem, back in full training
GoalsResult
DoubtfulTomás O'ConnorCM
muscle strain suffered against Boca Juniors
Result
Out
Dots = impact on the starting XI (1 squad depth, 3 key starter); tags name the markets the absence moves. From Mendoza and Buenos Aires match previews published on Friday 11 September. Defensa reported no absences.
06Expected XI
Vaccari keeps the 4-3-3 that has won three home league matches in a row; Franco replaces O'Connor with Ulises Sánchez.
Defensa Y JusticiaHome
Julio Vaccari
Gimnasia M.Away
Darío Franco
Ordered goalkeeper first, then each line left to right.
07Shape and plan
Who holds the ball
Defensa average 52 percent possession, Gimnasia 47, and Franco is happy to hand it over: 42 percent at Independiente, 43 at Gimnasia L.P., 41 at Independiente Rivadavia. Vaccari's side will have the ball for long spells and will have to break a low block rather than counter one. That is precisely the pattern of their 1-0 win over Platense, 56 percent of the ball and 1.08 expected goals.
Módica against the second ball
Gimnasia's away goals come from transition into one man. With 0.96 expected goals a game on the road they are not building sustained pressure; they are winning the ball and finding Módica. Santiago Sosa's screening in front of Damián Fernández and David Martínez is the single most important job on the pitch, and Defensa have conceded 0.70 expected goals a game at home doing exactly it.
The wide overload
Defensa take 5.0 corners a game and Gimnasia give up 4.9, and Barbona and Hausch have been the source of both the crosses and the corners. In Mendoza in May, Defensa won the corner count 7-2 and still lost, so the volume has to turn into shots on target, where they are at 4.21 a game against a league average of 8.06.
08Three duels
Agustín Módica
Gimnasia M. · ST
Gimnasia's away plan is to survive and find him. Without him against Boca they still scored twice, but eight of their 14 Clausura goals are his.
8 goals in 7 Clausura matches
Damián Fernández
Defensa Y Justicia · CB
The anchor of the back four through the 0.70 expected goals conceded per home game run, and the man who has to stay goalside of Módica's runs.
Juan Gutiérrez
Defensa Y Justicia · LW
Vaccari's most-used attacking midfielder and the one who turns 52 percent possession into shots; he has started every recent league match.
Facundo Lencioni
Gimnasia M. · LM
The outlet from deep. With O'Connor out, Lencioni carries more of the ball-progression load in a midfield three that will spend the night defending.
Part three
The call
Our verdict: how the match most likely goes, the score we would write down, and what would change our mind.
09How it could go
Three ways this match goes
Chance of each, out of 100 — most likely first
- 48%chanceMost likely
Defensa grind out the one goal
Gimnasia sit deep and concede the ball, as they did at Independiente with 42 percent possession. Defensa work it wide, take their five or six corners, and one of the four or five shots on target lands. Gimnasia's 0.96 expected goals a game on the road does not answer it.
- 29%chance
Another Tomaghello stalemate
The obvious alternative. Defensa hold the ball, make 1.3 or 1.4 expected goals and cannot finish; Gimnasia take the point and keep top spot. Defensa drew four of their last 10 home league matches, Gimnasia three of their last 10 away, and the league runs at 29 percent draws.
- 23%chance
Módica punishes the space
Defensa push on, Gimnasia break, and the striker with eight Clausura goals gets one clean sight of goal. Defensa have kept a single clean sheet in 13 league matches, so one chance is usually enough. It is how Gimnasia won 3-0 at Independiente on 0.65 expected goals.
The chances are the desk's judgement, not market prices; together they add up to 100.
Gimnasia M. lead Zone A on the strength of what they do in Mendoza. On the road they have made 0.96 expected goals a game. The Tomaghello, where Defensa have conceded 0.70 a game, is the wrong place to test it.
10The verdict
Defensa's home defence points to a low-scoring night
We make it Defensa Y Justicia 48 percent, the draw 29 and Gimnasia M. 23, against an odds probability of 47, 28 and 26 - close enough that no gap needs explaining, and the market favourite is where the verdict lands. Nothing in the crisis check moves it: both clubs are stable, both coaches secure, Franco at W8 D3 L3 in 14 matches since 29 March and Vaccari W4 D2 L3 in nine since his May return. The player checks decide the margin. Gimnasia lose Tomás O'Connor to a muscle strain and get Agustín Módica back from one, and while Módica carries eight of their 14 Clausura goals, they scored twice without him against Boca, so we grade his return as real but not decisive. What is decisive is the venue split. Gimnasia have 1.00 points a game and 0.96 expected goals from their last seven away matches, with the 3-0 at Independiente built on 0.65 expected goals; Defensa have 1.46 expected goals for and 0.70 against across their last seven at home, three straight home league wins and four unbeaten. Elo puts Gimnasia 70 points clear, home advantage is worth about that, and the sides are level on the night. Both venue profiles show over 2.5 goals in 40 percent of the last 10, and the league runs at 2.08 a match, so we write down 1-0. Confidence stays at 3: Defensa have one clean sheet in 13 league matches, and a single Módica chance undoes the whole shape.
What would change our mind
- If Módica is named on the bench rather than in the XI, the under 2.5 lean strengthens and the double chance holds.
- If the forecast rain arrives before kick-off, the low-scoring shape firms up and the level handicap becomes the better read of the result.
- If Defensa concede first, the draw becomes the live outcome and the double chance is what protects the call.
Quick answers
- Who is favourite for Defensa y Justicia vs Gimnasia Mendoza?
- Defensa y Justicia. The market prices them at 2.02 against 3.66 for Gimnasia M. and 3.40 for the draw, an odds probability of 47 percent. Our own reading is 48 percent Defensa, 29 percent draw, 23 percent Gimnasia M. Home advantage is worth roughly the 70 Elo points that separate the sides, so the Tomaghello turns a Gimnasia edge into a level match.
- Is Agustín Módica playing for Gimnasia Mendoza?
- He is expected to. Módica, the Clausura's leading scorer with eight goals in seven matches, missed the 2-2 draw with Boca Juniors on 5 September with a muscle problem. He returned to full training this week and the Mendoza previews name him in the probable XI, though no official medical bulletin was published.
- What is the head-to-head between these two?
- They have met once competitively this year. Gimnasia M. won 2-1 at home on 4 May in the Apertura, a match Defensa y Justicia shaded on shots, 11 to 8, and on corners, 7 to 2. It was level 1-1 at half-time.
- What is the predicted score?
- Defensa y Justicia 1-0 Gimnasia M. Defensa have taken 10 points from their four home Clausura matches, scoring six and conceding three, while their last seven home matches show 1.46 expected goals for and 0.70 against. Gimnasia have managed 0.96 expected goals a game in their last seven away matches.
- Who referees Defensa y Justicia vs Gimnasia Mendoza?
- Jorge Baliño, with Adrián Franklin on VAR. Baliño has shown 19 yellow cards and no red cards in seven matches this year, 2.71 a game, against a league average of 4.88 yellows per match across 375 fixtures this season.
Written 11 Sept 2026, 19:15 · Updated 11 Sept 2026, 19:15 UTC.
AI-generated match analysis for information and entertainment. Prices are indicative market averages, never an offer. Spotted an error? Tell the desk.
More previews

vs
Bundesliga · Round 3
FC Augsburg vs Bayer Leverkusen
Augsburg lead the table, Leverkusen own the better numbers, and this fixture has not drawn in eight meetings. Goals look likelier than caution.

vs
Bundesliga · Round 3
SC Freiburg vs Borussia Mönchengladbach
Five straight wins against no points at all. Gladbach have not beaten Freiburg in eight meetings and have conceded seven in two matches.

vs
Premier League · Matchweek 4
Bournemouth vs Brentford
Bournemouth have led at half-time in all three league matches and won none of them. The call is that the fourth one finally sticks.